Service Cases Summary dismissal of an earlier petition under Article 32 of the Constitution does not bar the present writ petition on grounds of res judicata as there has been no substantive decision on the merits of the issues. HELD Court must be alive to the contemporary reality of “ambush Public Interest Litigations” and interpret the principles of res judicata or constructive res judicata in a manner which does not debar access to justice – Jurisdiction under Article 32 is a fundamental right in and of itself. November 21, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Claim for compassionate appointment must be decided only on the basis of relevant scheme prevalent on date of demise of the employee and subsequent scheme cannot be looked into – Respondent shall not be entitled for appointment on compassionate ground on the basis of the subsequent circular/policy dated 31.08.2016 – Appeal allowed. November 21, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Mr. Dinkar Gupta was appointed as Director General of Punjab Police – HELD when a person takes a chance and participates, thereafter he cannot, because the result is unpalatable, turn around to contend that the process was unfair or the selection committee was not properly constituted. In case where the petitioner had appeared at an open interview, as the Appellant too had taken a calculated chance in spite of the stakes, that too without protest, and then has belatedly raised the plea of bias and prejudice only when he was not recommended. November 21, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Qualifications/conditions for selection to the post of Anganwadi Sevika – Clause 3(E) – Appointment – Post of Anganwadi Sevika – No distinction can be drawn between a married daughter and unmarried daughter for the purpose of considering the eligibility as per the guidelines November 21, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Service Law – Misconduct – Quantum of punishment – Scope of judicial review on the quantum of punishment is available but with a limited scope – Where the punishment imposed by the disciplinary authority is found to be shocking to the conscience of the Court, normally the disciplinary authority or the appellate authority should be directed to reconsider the question of imposition of penalty – after setting aside the penalty order, it is to be left to the disciplinary/appellate authority to take a call November 13, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases ‘ Creamy layer’ HELD Economic criterion cannot be the sole criterion for identifying ‘creamy layer’ – In spite of Section 5(2) of the 2016 Act making it mandatory for identification and exclusion of ‘creamy layer’ to be on the basis of social, economic and other relevant factors, the State of Haryana has sought to determine ‘creamy layer’ from backward classes solely on the basis of economic criterion and has committed a grave error in doing so August 30, 2021August 30, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Appointment of appellant can only be construed as irregular and not illegal – Appellant is held entitled to be regularized with all consequential benefits – Appeal allowed. Finding recorded by the Division Bench of the High Court in respect of nature of the appointment of the appellant being illegal is thus not liable to be sustained – Her rejection of the claim for regularization on the ground of her appointment being illegal by the impugned order is patently erroneous. August 22, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Seniority – cum – merit principle – Criterion of “seniority – cum – merit” in the matter of promotion postulates that given the minimum necessary merit requisite for efficiency of administration, the senior, even though less meritorious, shall have priority and a comparative assessment of merit is not required to be made August 7, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Penalty of compulsory retirement from the post of Additional District and Sessions Judge – Multiple transactions showing deposits and withdrawals of substantial amounts of money, it cannot be said that Full Court was not justified in taking the view that it did – Compulsory retirement upheld August 5, 2021 phlaw
Service Cases Service Law—Persons with Disabilities—Supernumerary post-Petitioner was working as science master—Met with a road accident and was permanently incapacitated for further service—Directions issued to pay salary to the petitioner as per norms by deeming fiction as if he is in service and has been working against a supernumerary post March 27, 2021 phlaw
